Our Facebook PageOur LinkedIn Page
 Call us at (801) 641-1571
  Send an email

5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr
Holladay, UT 84117
MLS #2157837

$1,995,000

 Available

4 Beds | 4 Baths | 0 Garage | 2,900 Sq Ft

Estimated Payment:  /month 
5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr
Photo 1 for 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr
Photo 2 for 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr
Photo 3 for 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr
Photo 4 for 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr
Photo 5 for 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr
Photo 6 for 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr

Photos, Tours, & Maps

Post It

Single Family Home for Sale

The approach to this home remains one of my favorites, characterized by massive aggregate facades. While this material is a common mid-century detail in commercial buildings, this home utilizes large aggregate wall forms that were cast flat and tilted into place. Stephen MacDonald favored this tilt-up construction for its efficiency and affordability, as well as its alignment with "soft modern" or organic modern design. These walls transition seamlessly from the interior to the outdoors, blurring the lines between the two environments, while post-and-beam construction ties the upper portion together with beautiful wood. The interior features a water feature that runs through the home like a stream, bisecting the main room. Large boulders, polished by years of use as stepping stones, enhance the organic aesthetic. Floor-to-ceiling glass walls at the rear open to a long fountain, ensuring the sound of water echoes throughout the property. The home retains its original mid-century architectural details, including beautifully integrated pegboard and pristine light wood veneer. To complement these features, Anne-Marie Barton has added subtle updates, including the art of Kintsugi adopted by my seller. This Japanese influence reflects Stephen MacDonald's own design history, such as his Millcreek office, which featured shoji screens. This home truly represents a perfect balance of architectural purity and thoughtful modern touches.

Rooms, Laundry, & Layout

 BedsBathsLaundrySq Ft
Floor 14412,900
Price Insights
Current price
Price per sq ft
Price per finished sq ft
$1,995,000
$688 / square foot
$688 / finished sq ft

2 Days on the Market
Status: Available

Schools, Inclusions, & Exclusions

Dryer, Hot Tub, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Trampoline
Inclusions are often re-negotiated during contract negotiation.
No items have been listed as excluded.

Granite School District

Elementary: Spring Lane
Middle: Bonneville
Senior: Cottonwood
The Numbers
Interior :
Style :
Year built :
Lot acres :
Lot sq ft :
2,900 square feet
Style: Rambler/Ranch
1964
.50 acres
21,780 square feet

Home Features & Amenities

Features: Bath: Primary, Separate Tub/Shower, Den/Office, Gas Log Fireplace, Great Room, Updated Kitchen, Vaulted Ceilings
Flooring: Carpet, Hardwood, Stone
Window Coverings: Drapes
Heating: Forced Air, Central Gas
Air Conditioning: Central Air
Utilities: Natural Gas Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Public Sewer, Water Connected

Private Showing

For showing appointments, call Jenn Kikel Lynn, Realtor® to view the home at 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr in Holladay. Give Jenn Kikel Lynn, Realtor® a call at (801) 641-1571.
5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr was listed on May 13th, 2026 by Summit Sotheby's International Realty, a real estate brokerage. 801-467-2100 is the contact info for the listing brokerage contact assigned for this listing.

 Mortgage Calculator

Estimated Monthly Payment
/ month*
Modify your down payment, price, or interest rate to estimate a payment.
Purchase Price $
Down Payment %
Interest Rate %
Repayment (years)
Property Tax $
HOA Fee $
Estimated payments and calculations are provided for informational purposes only. Actual payments can vary based on many factors.
*Insurance must usually be added to your monthly payment. Costs vary based on many factors. Consult your insurance agent, your Realtor®, and your lender.

Take it on the road with you...

QR code for 5457 S Cottonwood Club Dr.
Scan this QR code into your mobile device and take this listing with you.

If you have a smartphone, just point your camera at the code. This page will appear on your phone.

You May Also Like...


9623 S Tannenbaum Cv
                     MLS #2116371
$2,099,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
5,248 Sq Ft
405 N Silver King Dr #123
                     MLS #2130736
$2,100,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
1,560 Sq Ft
11318 S Canyon Falls Ln
                     MLS #2139506
$2,100,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
4,980 Sq Ft
3910 S 1040 E
                     MLS #2151403
$2,100,000
16 BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
7,376 Sq Ft
4345 S Highland Dr
                     MLS #2151411
$2,100,000
14 BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
7,072 Sq Ft
4611  Ponderosa Dr
                     MLS #2151510
$2,100,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
3,640 Sq Ft
4790 S Hugo Ave
                     MLS #2154560
$2,100,000
BedroomsBathroomsGarage spaces
2,740 Sq Ft
Scroll up
Scroll up

ClosingDealsInHighHeels.com shows ALL available properties from the MLS in Utah (WFRMLS), including any property that is pending, under contract, accepting backup offers, or actively seeking buyers.